by endo » Tue Jan 24, 2012 2:47 pm
He/she can be sensitive if he or she wants to be, I say! This community thrives at being able to express ourselves freely, including reacting offensively, and having to deal with our feelings about hurting other people's feelings.
While this thread is not about kids, I have notices that a lot of parents who bring their kids are VERY defensive about the topic...I am guessing that this is in part due to facing a constant negative reaction from others who see their choice as bad parenting. Just like a lot of us are viewed as sex-crazed, irresponsible drug addicts by people who have never been to burning man...which may be an accurate assessment, but it also may be way off the mark. We get a little defensive about this stuff. I have friends who have brought their kids and had an amazing and positive and totally responsible experience; I have had friends who did NOT have that experience, or whose kids were miserable.
My husband and I do not bring his kids (who live with us most of the time) mostly for the same reasons as shylar mentioned--WE do not want to have to behave responsibly.
But I think parents who get horribly offended by people who might not want kids at Burning Man are lacking in some compassion and maturity in seeing what others' issues might be. The reality is that a lot of us do stuff at burning man that we would not do with our kids. I know some parents see this as the height of hypocrisy, but if a person looks into issues surrounding child development, etc., there are some great reasons for kids to experience some of the things at burning man when they are older and have developed cognitive abilities such as the ability to perceive irony, etc. Also, kids are more vulnerable to dehydration and sunstroke than are adults, and the playa dust can cause lung damage in adults, as well as in kids. Look at childhood asthma statistics and exposure to particulates.
There are differences between kids and adults.
But there are also societal differences and legal differences between how adults are allowed to act with other adults versus children. Providing a child with alcohol is illegal; giving alcohol to adults is not. Getting a ticket for indecent exposure when a CHILD is involved can place you on a list of registered sex offenders. Most of us grown-ups have different boundaries with kids, and with different ages of kids, for moral as well as social/legal reasons.
At burning man, we push the boundaries in every direction. I have worn things at burning man I would not feel comfortable wearing at home...and my regular daily life is a lot more like burning man that many people's. I live where people are naked in front of each other regularly, where authenticity is allowed and prized, where people have group experiences with mind altering substances, and where people also have work and kids and are responsible.
Going to burning man means that I am around some of your children. And there are things I do not feel comfortable doing with them around, even if you do. There are things I could get arrested for if they are there, that I would not if they are not there. You bringing kids impacts my ability to do what I want to do safely. And, because I am seen as a safe and responsible person in my community, I also end up with babysitting duty sometimes when you leave for "just a few minutes," and return hours later to collect your child...I have seen even "responsible" parents seriously take advantage of those of us responsible parents who choose not to bring our children.
So is the solution to have no kids? From my perspective, people should do what they feel comfortable doing at burning man, responsible or not. I am willing to have my experience changed by my fellow humans, even the short ones. If some mom wanders off after smoking a J and leaves her kid with me for a few extra hours, I will feed her snacks, make sure she does not get too much dust in her lungs, make sure she is hydrated, move her away from the guy with his penis died up with string who is screaming about the fist-fucking workshop, and so forth. Because those are MY values, and I get to be who I want to be, too.
And as for my own step-kids, I support my husband's choice not to bring him. Partly for our own fun, but also because I want my eleven your old step-daughter to experience burning man when she is old enough to see that all the chicks decked out in sexy clothes are not just how women are supposed to act (a message that could be communicated as easily by bringing her to a Vegas chorus line or by watching re-runs of Babe Watch or whatever the current equivalent is), but that the fact that the 300 pound 50 year old and the 25 year old hotty are both dressed in sexy clothes because they are TOTALLY FREE TO EXPRESS THEMSELVES without the judgment of others, and that the culture of burning man is that none of us possess those hotties, that their dressing hot does not give us the right to harass, dominate, or control them. They are allowed to be powerful. We all are. My large breasts are complimented rather than oogled and grabbed. I think some of the more outrageous elements of burning man are a reaction to our oppressive and exploitative culture, and I would not want the kids to read that expression as validating the worst parts of our culture. For my step-daughters, the fact that they are not allowed to have barbies at dads still does not entirely make sense. In a couple of years, barbie death camp will make more sense. So far, the kids have been exposed to a culture that does little to objectify women compared to the larger american culture, so their appreciation of the ways burning man both embodies and spoofs our culture at the same time will have to wait a little, maybe until they are older.
My husband says to his girls that they can come to burning man when they can legally and practically drive themselves and an RV there. But sometimes I wonder...if burning man is no longer happening in 5 or ten years, will we regret not having them see this most amazing artistic and social experiment I have seen thus far? I am sure we will.
So kudos to shylar for concerns about kids present at burning man, and kudos to the people who bring their kids and expressed offense. Maybe y'all could be a little more tolerant of other people's emotions. Of course you hurt his feelings, you were mean; be nice, because when you bring your kids, that makes us be their parents, too, at least a little bit. We are doing something for you by helping to care for your kids, like it or not. And shylar, Of course they are going to freak out, they bring their kids and have probably been hammered by all kinds of folks who object.
--endo